Oakville Images
Two Stores In Oakville, Ontario; The J & A Beatty Store and the William Creighton Store. By Bob Johnson, March 2021
:
Description
Mystery Question
Do you know who was running the store in Oakville for James Beatty in the period 1835-7?
[Please answer by clicking on the Comments tab]
Creator
Bob Johnson, Author
Media Type
Text
Image
Item Type
Documents
Description
To read this authoritative history of the two Oakville, Ontario stores, click on "Pages - Select" to read without downloading, or download by clicking on the "PDF" version.

The paper includes photographs of both stores. Today's 215 Lakeshore Road East was the Beatty store, the Creighton store is now 184-186 Lakeshore Road. Both are Designated Heritage properties.

Re the "mystery question" request for information, and to give you a glimpse of the author's excellent research and writing:

"Hence, in 1835, when James felt he was in a position to open another outlet, he bought the store in Oakville that I call the Beatty store. The purchase is interesting and sheds some light on the construction of the store. The first purchase was two back-to-back lots bought from William Butts for 400 pounds. This price was a very high markup from the price of 60 pounds Butts paid the original developer William Chisholm in 1833. This clearly indicates the purchase included some substantial building or buildings added by Butts even though none are mentioned. The second purchase was bought directly from Chisholm. The price of 77 pounds was similarly marked up considering the tiny size of the land included. The designated heritage store actually spans the land of both purchases. Both purchase documents were signed at the same time with Chisholm even witnessing Butts purchase. Considered together, it seems most likely that Butts and Chisholm contracted with James Beatty to build a store to his specification. Butts probably committed to the erection, while Chisholm (who owned a sawmill) provided the lumber. This explains why James Beatty was able to buy an existing store spanning land owned by two different people.

I know that James bought the store in 1835, but I am pretty sure he himself stayed in Toronto and continued to run his store there. He would have appointed someone to manage the store for him but I have no clear proof who that person was."

1836 saw the start of financial trouble for James. In 1837 the outbreak of war, plus the financial situation of American banks and then Canadian banks stopping hard cash payments, resulting in a loss of British investment money a scarcity of hard cash in Upper
Notes
The Oakville Historical Society, the Trafalgar Township Historical Society, the Bronte Historical Society and the Town of Oakville Heritage Planning Department have been able to assist.
Subject(s)
Local identifier
TTR(BOB)J0001026
Collection
Trafalgar Township Historical Society
Language of Item
English
Geographic Coverage
  • Ontario, Canada
    Latitude: 43.4460129259218 Longitude: -79.6681142062378
  • Ontario, Canada
    Latitude: 43.4455879783115 Longitude: -79.6682805031968
Copyright Statement
Copyright status unknown. Responsibility for determining the copyright status and any use rests exclusively with the user.
Recommended Citation
Two Stores In Oakville, Ontario; The J & A Beatty Store and the William Creighton Store. By Bob Johnson, March 2021
Contact
Trafalgar Township Historical Society
Email:michelle@tths.ca
Website:

Trafalgar Township Historical Society Sponsor: Jeff Knoll, Local & Regional Councillor for Oakville Ward 5 – Town of Oakville/Regional Municipality of Halton
Powered by / Alimenté par VITA Toolkit




My favourites lets you save items you like, tag them and group them into collections for your own personal use. Viewing "My favourites" will open in a new tab. Login here or start a My favourites account.

thumbnail








Two Stores In Oakville, Ontario; The J & A Beatty Store and the William Creighton Store. By Bob Johnson, March 2021


To read this authoritative history of the two Oakville, Ontario stores, click on "Pages - Select" to read without downloading, or download by clicking on the "PDF" version.

The paper includes photographs of both stores. Today's 215 Lakeshore Road East was the Beatty store, the Creighton store is now 184-186 Lakeshore Road. Both are Designated Heritage properties.

Re the "mystery question" request for information, and to give you a glimpse of the author's excellent research and writing:

"Hence, in 1835, when James felt he was in a position to open another outlet, he bought the store in Oakville that I call the Beatty store. The purchase is interesting and sheds some light on the construction of the store. The first purchase was two back-to-back lots bought from William Butts for 400 pounds. This price was a very high markup from the price of 60 pounds Butts paid the original developer William Chisholm in 1833. This clearly indicates the purchase included some substantial building or buildings added by Butts even though none are mentioned. The second purchase was bought directly from Chisholm. The price of 77 pounds was similarly marked up considering the tiny size of the land included. The designated heritage store actually spans the land of both purchases. Both purchase documents were signed at the same time with Chisholm even witnessing Butts purchase. Considered together, it seems most likely that Butts and Chisholm contracted with James Beatty to build a store to his specification. Butts probably committed to the erection, while Chisholm (who owned a sawmill) provided the lumber. This explains why James Beatty was able to buy an existing store spanning land owned by two different people.

I know that James bought the store in 1835, but I am pretty sure he himself stayed in Toronto and continued to run his store there. He would have appointed someone to manage the store for him but I have no clear proof who that person was."

1836 saw the start of financial trouble for James. In 1837 the outbreak of war, plus the financial situation of American banks and then Canadian banks stopping hard cash payments, resulting in a loss of British investment money a scarcity of hard cash in Upper